Comprehensive Plan: The site is consists of two platted outlots (Outlots L and M, Cobblestone Lake Commercial 3rd Addition), which are currently guided “HD” (High Density Residential/6-12 units per acre). High Density Residential areas include multiple-family structures (apartments and condominiums) at densities greater than twelve units per acre to the extent allowed by the zoning ordinance. Developments with densities of up to 40 units per acre are allowed in the areas within and adjacent to the downtown if certain performance standards in the zoning code are met. This designation fits with M-7, M-8 and PD zoning districts to the extent allowed when considered with parking, infiltration, lot coverage, and building setbacks. Areas of manufactured housing are allowed as conditional uses in the M-7 zoning district. The proposed project is generally consistent with the Comprehensive Plan designation.
Livable Communities Impact: The proposed multi-family development will provide 196 market-rate apartments. This development proposal will address the City’s Livable Communities Act (LCA) principles of adding a housing product that helps provide a balanced supply and variety of housing types for people of all income levels and lifecycle stages.
Zoning: The development site is located in Planned Development No. 703. Outlot L is currently located in zone 7 of the planned development. Permitted uses within this zone include parks and playgrounds, recreational buildings, community centers and structures, and public utility buildings and structures. This outlot was intended to become part of Cobblestone Lake development’s public park system and was to be the location of a section of the North Creek Greenway, an enhanced trail that travels through Eagan, Apple Valley, Lakeville, Farmington and Empire Township. Staff and the developer have had discussions with Dakota County and they are receptive to relocating this section of trail to an area proposed in Outlot L to just north of the proposed development.
Outlot M is located in zone 8 of the planned development. This zone was established to allow for sand and gravel mining as an interim use with the intent that rezoning of properties in this zone would occur at the time of the former submittal and approval of development proposal.
It was initially thought to incorporate the subject property into zone 6, which currently allows for a variety of commercial/office/retail uses, as well as senior apartments and continuum of care facilities. Staff believes that creating a new zone that would list apartments as a permitted use would be better. Therefore, staff is recommending that the property be rezoned to zone 5, and permitted, conditional and accessory uses be established, as well as area requirements and special performance standards consistent with high-density residential development.
Preliminary Plat:
The site is currently platted as two outlots. An outlot is defined as a platted lot to be developed for uses which will not involve a building or be reserved for future replatting before development. Outlot M was established as a reserve area that would be replatted for high-density residential development and Outlot L was intended to be dedicated for public park purposes that would include a trail.
The original preliminary plat indicated that the applicant would replat the two outlots into a 11.9-acre lot and a .5-acre outlot. The proposed lot would be the location of 196-unit apartment development and the new outlot, which would be located between the north property line of the lot and the Cobblestone Lake Parkway right-of-way would replace Outlot L and would be the new location of a section of the North Creek Greenway trail and three infiltration basins that would collect storm water runoff from the development.
The City informed the applicant that infiltration basins that receives runoff from private developments cannot be established on public property or property that it is not generating the storm water runoff. There was concern on how the developer would maintain these off-site basins on public property. Therefore, staff proposed that the outlot be eliminated and a drainage, utility, and trail easement be established over that area. This would eliminate the access for maintenance issue and would allow for the establishment of the Greenway trail section. It is expected that the area dedicated for the trail would be equivalent to the area of Outlot L.
Ten-foot wide drainage and utility easements abut the majority of the north and south property lines of Outlot M and the east property of Outlot L. These easements will remain as part of the replat.
Easements have been established that restrict direct access to Pilot Knob Road and 160th Street as well as a right-of-way reservation area that describes additional land along Pilot Knob Road and 160th Street for the purpose of constructing a future interchange at the intersection of those two roads. The easement and reservation area shall remain in place with the proposed replat.
Easements that restrict access to Cobblestone Lake Parkway and Elmhurst Lane except where noted on the site should be established.
Site Plan:
The applicant is proposing to construct thirteen two-story apartment buildings, eleven detached garage buildings, and a 4,400-sq. ft. clubhouse facility. Ten buildings will have 16 units each, with the remaining three will have 12 units per building.
Eleven detached garage buildings, varying in size, will be scattered throughout the site and will provide 80 parking spaces. Together with the 116 attached and 26 tandem garage spaces, the applicant is proposing 79 driveway spaces, and 135 on-site surface parking spaces that include the 20 spaces in front of the clubhouse. The proposed site parking will provide 2.2 spaces per unit, which is below the minimum code required 2.5 spaces per unit. The zoning code allows for and upward or downward revision based on accessibility of the open parking spaces to all tenants and guests of a multiple dwelling complex. The applicant should provide sound data that supports their request for a 54-space reduction from the minimum requirement.
In an effort to meet the minimum parking requirement, the applicant identified 34 on-street parking spaces along Cobblestone Lake Parkway and Elmhurst Lane into their parking equation. The applicant was informed that parking on a public street cannot be used to meet the minimum parking requirements.
The original site plan indicated that the surface parking spaces will be 9 feet wide and 18 feet long, which is .5 feet shorter than the City’s minimum standard for a parking space that is adjacent to a curb. City code requires that parking spaces shall not be less than nine feet wide and 20 feet in length. If a space is adjacent to a curb or landscaped area, the required length of the space can be reduced by 1.5 feet. The plans show sidewalks located directly behind the curbs, which can limit its use with parked cars encroaching 1.5 feet over them. Also, all drive aisles shall be a minimum of 24 feet wide.
Staff recommended revisions be made to bring the parking spaces into conformance with the minimum standards. The applicant has stated in their March 26, Project Description that all surface space will have a minimum dimension of 9 feet x 18.5 feet.
The plan identifies 79 driveway parking spaces in front of some of units, that will be 18 feet deep. To be consistent with other multi-family developments within Cobblestone Lake, the driveways should have minimum length of 20 feet. The applicant has stated that driveway parking spaces will have a minimum dimension of 9 feet x 20 feet.
The plan also shows parking spaces encroaching into a drainage and utility easement along the east side of the property. All parking spaces shall be located outside of any drainage and utility easements and should be set back a minimum of ten feet, which will avoid any conflicts for users of the easement.
Access to the development will be via one driveway located along the west side of Elmhurst Lane, and a second along Cobblestone Lake Parkway. The site will be completely fenced and the access drives will be secured. Residents will only have access to the Elmhurst Lane gate, with the other driveway accessible by emergency personnel only.
The site plan shows the apartment buildings being set back approximately 65-75 feet from Pilot Knob Road, 38-45 feet from 160th Street West, 20 feet from Elmhurst Lane, 55-65 feet from Cobblestone Lake Parkway, and 15-25 feet from the north property line. Three garage buildings and several surface parking spaces are located approximately 27 feet from the south property line.
Existing area requirements require senior apartment and commercial buildings in "PD-703" to be set back a minimum of 50 feet from a principal or arterial street (Pilot Knob Road and 160th Street West), 15 feet from a local street (Cobblestone Lake Parkway and Elmhurst Lane) and 20 feet from a rear property . An exception has been established for buildings on property adjacent to the Pilot Knob Road/160th Street right-of-way reservation area. They allow buildings south of 157th Street West to be set back a minimum of 25 feet from the reservation area.
The development will have fencing around the perimeter of the site. The applicant initially proposed erecting a five-foot high decorative fence with 2-ft. x 2-ft. integrally spaced masonry columns along the north, east and a portion of the south side of the property. A five-foot tall vinyl clad chain-link fence be installed along most of the south and all the west property line. Because of the significant grades, the chain-link fencing will not be visible from the adjacent public roadways.
The submitted plans show a retaining wall that will extend from the northwest corner of the site south to the southwest corner and approximately 285 feet east along the south property line. The wall will be 16 feet tall at it highest point. Concern has been raised by Dakota County about the potential encroachment of the retaining wall support infrastructure into the right-of-way reservation area. Issuance of any building permits shall be contingent upon approval by the City and Dakota County of before-mentioned retaining wall.
The developer has provided a building construction phasing plan and staging plan, which shows the timing of building construction, location of any job site trailer, construction materials storage, and parking for construction workers to ensure limited disruption to adjacent properties. The plan indicates that trades parking will be on the public street. Onsite parking shall be provided for their construction workers. Also, the temporary construction access drive along Cobblestone Lake Parkway will not be allowed.
Grading Plan: The site has been graded as part of the sand and gravel mining reclamation of the site. Grading to accommodate the proposed development will be needed prior to construction. Site grading shall occur in conformance with a Natural Resources Management Plan (NRMP) which shall include final grading plan to be submitted for review and approval by the City Engineer.
Availability of Municipal Utilities: Existing utilities will be extended into the site to serve the development. Utility construction shall occur in conformance with a final utility plan to be submitted for review and approval by the City Engineer.
The applicant is proposing to install several infiltration basins and a subsurface infiltration system that would collect storm water from the proposed development. An agreement will need to be executed that would require that the owner of the apartment complex be responsible for ongoing maintenance of the basins.
Elevation Drawings: Building exterior materials for the apartment buildings will consist of a variety of masonry, cement lap and vertical board and batten siding. The clubhouse will have a similar mix of materials.
The developer's initial plans showed use of masonry for the column bases and a few areas of the building’s elevations. Staff expressed concerns regarding the amount of masonry proposed for the buildings and recommended that the developer consider adding more masonry to the buildings.
The developer has submitted plans that show an increase in the amount of masonry to the all the buildings.
Landscape Plan:
A landscape plan has been submitted that identifies the location of a variety of plant materials. and includes a detailed list of plant materials. All the proposed materials should consist of a healthy mix of species that will be conducive to the existing site conditions and provide an aesthetically pleasing development. Staff would like to see additional plantings along the edge of the property adjacent to the Greenway trail.
Street Classifications/Accesses/Circulation:
Although the site is surrounding by public streets, access to and from the development will be only be available via Elmhurst Lane. Staff had concern with development having only one access to and from the site for the general public and residents. The applicant provided information showing trip distribution to and from the site and potential impacts to the surrounding intersections, which was reviewed by the City Engineer. No outstanding issues were identified.
Pedestrian Access:
The site plan shows a network of internal sidewalks to serve the development. The sidewalk widths vary in size from 3.5 to 5 feet in width. The minimum width of all sidewalks should be five feet and any gaps should be filled in to provide better access throughout the site.
Two gates will be installed in the fence along the north side of the site that will provide access from the complex to the greenway trail and sidewalk along Cobblestone Lake Parkway. Sidewalks should be extended and a pedestrian gate should be installed to provide access to the sidewalk along the west side of Elmhurst Lane.
Signs: A sign package has been submitted that shows a 48-sq. ft. monument sign located in the northwest corner of the site, along Pilot Knob Road and 20-sq. ft. of building signage. All signage shall be in conformance with the City's current sign regulations.
Dakota County Review: Because the proposed subdivision is located adjacent to Pilot Knob Road and 160th Street West, two County roads, it is subject to review by the Dakota County Plat Commission. The Commission reviewed this development proposal on February 5, 2018. Their comments are included in the attached letter.
Public Hearing Comments: The public hearing was held on February 21, 2018. The hearing was opened, no comments from the public was received comments and the hearing was closed.