ACTION REQUESTED:
No official action is needed. The owner wishes to receive feedback concerning the proposed revised plans. It is recommended that the Planning Commission not state specifically whether or not they would approve or deny the request, but rather, identify the specific zoning questions or issues they might have with the proposed project.
SUMMARY:
Menard, Inc. has submitted revised plans for a proposed development of 50.5 acres of property located at the northwest corner of CSAH 42 and Johnny Cake Ridge Road. The submitted plans identify a 210,000-sq. ft. store and 420-space surface parking lot on 20 acres, 18 acres of future office/office warehouse development, and five acres of storm water ponding/open area. The remaining land area would be public road right-of-way.
The petitioner has submitted two sets of revised plans. One set includes a proposed land use, site, bike and pedestrian circulation, and phasing plans that focuses specifically on 20-acre development and the second set lays out plans for the full 50.5-acre site.
The site is adjacent to the Williams Bros. petroleum tank farm to the west and vacant land to the north. These properties are guided for industrial and zoned for general industrial uses. Uponor and Venstar industrial park are located to the east on property that is guided for industrial and zoned for limited industrial uses. To the south is the Fischer Sand and Aggregate mining operation. This property is guided "Mixed Business Campus" and is currently zoned for gravel mining and agricultural uses.
The original request for development on this property was submitted in October 2015. The applicant was asking for a re-designation on the Comp Plan Land Use Map of the southwest 16.5 acres from "IND" (Industrial) to “C” (Commercial) to allow for commercial/retail uses, with the remaining property designated “MBC” (Mixed Business Campus). Also included was a request for an amendment to the text of the Comprehensive Plan to allow for select areas north of CSAH 42, adjacent to the South Planning Area, to be designated "MBC". The applicant revised their original plans in 2016, and submitted a request asking that the southwest 19 acres be re-designated for commercial uses, with the remaining property retaining its current "IND" (Industrial) designation. This revised request also eliminated the need for a Comp Plan text amendment.
The applicant also requested that the property be rezoned from “I-2” (General Industrial) to “PD” (Planned Development) to allow for the retail uses on 19 acres and a mix of medical office, office and industrial uses on the remaining property.
A public hearing on the proposed amendments to the Comprehensive Plan and Land Use Map and the rezoning requests was held on November 4, 2015. Two comments were received regarding potential traffic impacts. The first was from Mike Erdmann, a resident, who expressed concern for the amount of additional traffic, head of household jobs, reducing the amount of industrial land and the need for job creation. The second was from Dan Hughes, Director, Real Estate, Security and EHS for Uponor North America, who also expressed concern for traffic on Johnny Cake Ridge Road. Several Commissioners also commented on the loss of industrial property and potential head of household jobs that many times comes with industrial development.
As is the normal procedure, the proposed Comp Plan amendments were sent to adjacent communities, the two school districts serving Apple Valley, the Metropolitan Council, representatives of watershed districts in the city, MnDOT, and Dakota County for their review and comment. A comment was received from the City of Lakeville who expressed concern about the impact this proposal would have on their street system, in particular Flagstaff Avenue. They requested that the applicant prepare a traffic study that would analyze the potential impacts the proposed development would have on the existing and future roadway system. The applicant prepared a study, which was reviewed by the City Engineer and Bolton & Menk on behalf of the City. The traffic issues raised during the public hearing and by the City of Lakeville were addressed in the report.
The City also engaged Bolton & Menk to study the impacts that the proposed development would have on traffic to Johnny Cake Ridge Road and provide several scenarios for improvements. Their study concluded that additional turn lanes, roundabouts at 148th and 149th Streets West and a signal at the 147th Street West intersection would be needed to accommodate Menard's development. These improvements that will impact direct access to and from property along the east side of the street, include limiting direct driveway access to the Holiday motor fuel/convenience store, south of 149th Street West; and the Lifetime Fitness building driveway from a full to a right in/right out only access, were presented to the Planning Commission at their October 19, 2016, meeting.
Two property owners, who own property directly adjacent to the east of the Menard site spoke about the proposed Johnny Cake Ridge Road improvements at the October 19, 2016, Planning Commission meeting. James Madsen of James Barton Design Build, Inc., expressed his concern about the proposed improvements and the impact to his property. The City Engineer indicated that the proposed changes are conceptual at this point in time and the City will go through a detailed design process where Mr. Madsen's issues we will be addressed.
The second speaker, Dave Edquist, Manager of Real Estate for Holiday Station Stores, commented that Holiday initially had concerns with the ¾-turn access that was originally proposed but they really appreciated Menard, Inc. and the City’s input and time spent with coming up with a plan that would work and function far better than what they were looking at initially. He said they believe that the proposed conceptual plan would work and he appreciated everyone’s efforts to look at both sides.
At that October 19, the Planning Commission voted 3-2 to recommend denial of the proposed Comprehensive Plan amendment and rezoning of the property from "I-2" (General Industrial) to "PD" (Planned Development). The Commission' s recommendation was forwarded to the City Council.
The City Council considered the request at their meeting of December 8, 2016, at which time concerns were raised regarding potential loss of industrial zoned property, potential future uses of the property, property valuation, infrastructure improvements, as well as other issues. The City Council also inquired about what assurances the applicant could provide regarding the reuse of the existing store. It was suggested that preparation of a pre-development agreement/contract might be an instrument that would address infrastructure improvements, development phasing and reuse of the existing store. Menard, Inc. asked and was granted a tabling of the request so that they could explore the pre-development agreement/contract option.
The applicant submitted information in a letter dated February 2, 2017, that detailed what their commitment will be with this development. They agreed to language in the planned development ordinance that will limit the uses on the property they control and that a landmark corner will be created at the northwest corner of Johnny Cake Ridge Road and CSAH 42. They also indicated that they would incur the costs associated with public street and utility improvements with the exception of a southbound left-turn lane at the intersection of Johnny Cake Ridge Road and CSAH 42 and two-thirds the cost of the signal at 147th Street West and Johnny Cake Ridge Road. And finally, they have committed that any redevelopment at the existing store will not include tenants currently located in the City unless it involves the expansion of an additional location or their employment base in the city.
The request was considered again by the City Council on February 9, 2017. They voted 4-1 to approve submitting to the Metropolitan Council an amendment to the 2030 Land Use Map of the Comp Plan changing the designation of the south 19 acres of the subject property from "IND" (Industrial) to "C" (Commercial). The Metropolitan Council reviewed the proposed amendment and sent a letter of no objection to the City in March 2017.
Since that time, the applicant has been working on their development plans, which culminated in the revised plans submitted for your review and comment. Included with their revised plans is a letter that outlines their commitments to the public/private improvements associated with the proposed development and reuse of the existing store.
BACKGROUND:
Comprehensive Plan: The subject property is currently guided "IND” (Industrial) on the 2030 Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map. This category allows offices, assembly, warehouse, manufacturing and other similar activities within an enclosed building to limit the amount of dust, noise, odor and other adverse impacts. The current zoning district categories that regulate industrial uses include “I-1” (Limited Industrial), “I-2” (General Industrial) and “BP” (Business Park). A limited percentage of floor space (10% of gross floor area) is permitted for retail activities accessory to the industrial uses.
The original request identified 16.5 acres of commercial, 14.1 acres of medical office and 8.75 acres of industrial use. The applicant proposed that the 16.5 acres be re-designated “C” (Commercial) and the 22.85 acres of medical office and industrial be re-designated “MBC” (Mixed Business Campus). The “C” (Commercial) designation is intended for a wide variety of retail, office, and service uses that vary in intensity and off-site impacts. Retail uses typically encompass the traditional community shopping businesses and occupy much of the downtown area. It is intended to accommodate a wide range of commercial goods and services. Off-site impacts include activity, light, noise and generally higher traffic generation rates than other commercial uses. Retail land uses will be zoned “RB” Retail Business), “SC” (Shopping Center), and “PD” (Planned Development), which allows uses according to the specific performance standards:
- High quality site and architectural design and building materials are expected to be used within this land use category to promote pleasing off-site views of the development;
- Development in the downtown area shall adhere to the Downtown Design Guidelines;
- Landscaping shall be installed to provide aesthetic treatment of buildings and to soften parking lot areas;
- Significant traffic generation during the weekday and weekends is associated with retail development. Traffic studies may be requested in conjunction with the review of large developments that have the potential to threaten the integrity of the existing and planned roadway system. Additionally, developments that lower the level of service on adjacent roadways or intersections may be required to install traffic improvements to improve the level of service to its pre-development condition if City approval is granted;
- Driveway access points to the development shall be from non-local streets or those designed for primarily non-residential traffic. No direct access to County Road #42 and Cedar Avenue shall be allowed; and
- Lighting is limited to parking lot and building illumination designed for employee safety.
The “MBC” designation is intended to be high quality settings for office campus, office with light industrial, office with biomedical manufacturing, health care facilities, health care training, general office, corporate office, and other higher intensity employment uses that will create job opportunities in the community.
Mixed retail and commercial service uses that serve the campus and adjacent neighborhoods will be limited to activities that support the employment objectives of the Mixed Business campus. Examples of supporting uses would include lodging, restaurants, daycare, banking and other retail uses that may support the campus and adjacent neighborhoods.
The mix of uses in the MBC district includes the following:
- A range of 55% to 65% office, 10% to 20% light industry/manufacturing,
10% office warehouse/showroom, and
- 5% commercial and retail uses generally supportive of the campus and surrounding neighborhoods.
The “MBC” land use designation specifically applies to property in the South Central Planning Area (SCPA). Therefore, the applicant requested a text amendment to that statement to include “select areas north of County Road 42 adjacent to the South Central Planning Area”.
2016 Proposal: The applicant revised their site plan in 2016, which proposed 19 acres of commercial, 9.25 acres of medical office and 8.75 acres of industrial property. The proposed commercially designated property would be developed for 207,000-sq. ft. Menard’s store on Parcel 4 and 118,000 sq. ft. of office/medical office uses on Parcels 5 and 6. Parcel 3 would be reserved for future expansion of the Menard’s store or another commercial use(s). Parcel 2 would the future location of the ISD 196 transportation hub facility that was previously proposed for property at the northeast corner of 147th Street West and Johnny Cake Ridge Road. Finally, Parcel 1 would be the location of a storm water pond and a section of the North Creek Greenway.
It did not appear that the applicant’s original and revised proposals would meet the criteria set forth in the “MBC” designation. Therefore, staff recommended that the existing “IND” designation remain on Parcels 1, 2. 5 and 6 of the 2016 plan. The industrial and business park zoning districts allow for offices as permitted uses and certainly, a planned development district would be able to establish uses that would include both industrial and medical office uses consistent with the designation.
The 2018 submittal package is generally consistent with the 2016 proposal.
Zoning: The property is currently zoned “I-2” (General Industrial). General industrial districts are designed to serve the smaller “quasi-industrial” uses, such as machine shops, sign shops, mill-working establishments, and the like.
Two rezoning options were available for the City to consider with the original and the 2016 proposals. The first would be to rezone the properties consistent with the proposed Comp Plan designations. The second, which is the applicant’s and the City’s preference, would be to rezone the property to “PD” (Planned Development). A planned development would provide the following:
- A more creative and efficient approach to the use of land;
- Allow for a variety in the types of environment available to the people of the city;
- Encourage more efficient allocation and maintenance of privately controlled open space in residential developments through the distribution of overall density of population and intensity of the land use where an arrangement is desired and feasible;
- Provide the means for greater creativity and flexibility in environmental design than is provided under the strict application of the zoning and subdivision chapters while at the same time preserving the health, safety, order, convenience, prosperity and general welfare of the city and its inhabitants;
- Encourage an overall design within the natural boundaries for an area; and
- Provide an overall guide for developments that are staged because of the size of an area.
Staff believes that the planned development rezoning to a planned development is still a viable option with the 2018 revisions. It allows the City to negotiate with the land owner/developer on the type of uses, site coverage, area requirements and performance standards, and development phasing.
Site Plan: The 2018 conceptual site plan shows a one-level 210,000-sq. ft. Menard’s store and 420-space parking lot on 20 acres in the southwest corner of site. The plan also shows potential building footprints and parking areas on the remaining lots in the development. In the northwest corner of the site is an existing storm water holding pond on five acres. The pond currently collects storm water generated from the site. It is expected that this pond will be incorporated into the City’s storm water management system and may likely be the location of a section of the North Creek Greenway, which will run along the west side of the project area north from CSAH 42 to 147th Street West.
Building Elevations: The applicant has submitted conceptual building elevations for review. The south elevation of the building will be constructed with precast panels that will be clad with red brick and tan block. The west elevation will be constructed with a tan split-face block. The north elevation with have an exterior finish consisting of a combination of tan colored split-face block, green metal panels and clear polycarbonate panels. Tan colored split-face block will be the exterior finish of the east elevation. The building elevations will receive more scrutiny at the time of a formal application.
Street Classifications/Accesses/Circulation: Access to the site will be via CSAH 42, a principal arterial road, Johnny Cake Ridge Road, a major collector street and 147th Street West, a minor collector street. The westerly CSAH 42 intersection will be a ¾-intersection (right in/right out/left in only). The easterly CSAH 42 intersection will be a right in/right out only.
Significant improvements to Johnny Cake Ridge Road will be need to accommodate the additional traffic generated from development on the subject property. They include:
- A raised median from 147th Street West to CSAH 42;
- Roundabouts at 148th and 149th Streets West;
- A right in/right out only access at the driveway entrances to the Holiday convenience store and Lifetime Fitness building; and
- Additional turn lanes on Johnny Cake Ridge Road at CSAH 42 and 147th Streets West intersections.
The dedication of additional road right-of-way to accommodate the suggested improvements, which will require the relocation of the Great River Energy electrical transmission line outside of the right-of-way; and
Improvements to CSAH 42 would also occur with development on the subject property.
A right in/right out intersection is proposed an eighth of a mile west of the Johnny Cake Ridge Road intersection and a ¾-intersection one-half mile west of the intersection.
All of these roadway improvements will require the dedication of additional right-of-way for CSAH 42 and Johnny Cake Ridge Road.
The two access driveways along CSAH 42 are revisions from previous plans. Staff does have concern about the right-in/right-out access on CSAH 42 and asked that the applicant submit additional traffic information pertaining to the proposed changes. Attached is that information and the City's review of the information. Staff would like to go back to Dakota County to get their input on the impacts the revised plans will have on CSAH 42.
Pedestrian Access: The applicant has submitted a bike and pedestrian circulation plan, which identifies the location a section of the North Creek Greenway and sidewalks/pathways along the south side of 147th Street West, 148th Street West and Johnny Cake Ridge Road. Sidewalks are shown on both sides of all streets within the proposed development. Sidewalk connections from to the development sites to the public pedestrian system should be incorporated into each phase of development.
Phasing Plan: The first phase of development will be the Menard's store, the storm water ponding area, 149th Street West and a new public street that will intersect with 147th Street West and the right in/right out only intersection along CSAH 42. The remaining development is expected to occur in 2020 or later.
BUDGET IMPACT:
It is estimated that over $10 million in infrastructure improvements will be necessary to accommodate the development as proposed. Those improvements include:
- A traffic signal at 147th Street West and Johnny Cake Ridge Road.
- A regional storm water pond in the northwest corner of the site.
- Roadway improvements to Johnny Cake Ridge Road and CSAH 42.
- Onsite geotechnical corrections.
- Relocation of the transmission lines along the west side of Johnny Cake Ridge Road.
- Street and utility improvements to serve the development.
Menard, Inc. has indicated that they will pay for the CSAH 42 improvements, all the public street and utility construction improvements within the project area, including a regional storm water pond; and all Johnny Cake Ridge Road improvements with the exception of a southbound left-turn lane and a third of the cost for the signal at 147th Street West and Johnny Cake Ridge Road.
|